Review of just war against terror by jean bethke elshtain. What can go wrong in the war against terrorism, and is just war theory equally helpful in thinking about this war where the scare quotes are always necessary. Oct 05, 2001 she is author of augustine and the limits of politics. The fundamental issues from a just war perspective, there are at least two issues to be addressed at the outset when considering terrorism. Just war theory is the traditional approach taken to questions of the morality of war, but war today is far from traditional. In this hardhitting book, elshtain advocates just war in times of crisis and. Second, how is terrorism chosenpicked out of all the possible political strategies.
She lives in nashville, tennessee and chicago, illinois. In earlier books i articulate three principles of jus post bellum. To the extent that just war theory is followed, it is a prescription for suicide for innocent nations, and thus a profoundly unjust code. Michael walzer on terrorism and just war institute for advanced. How does this book relate to your own work on terrorism. Just war theory deals with the justification of how and why wars are fought. In this article i develop my analysis of the discourse that constructs the. It begins by broadly endorsing michael walzers assessment of terrorism in just and. Islam, islamist politics, terrorism, just wars, justwar theory, iraq. Walzers book just and unjust wars set the standard for the discipline, and mcmahans work including his book killing in war innovates just war theory, in part by challenging some of walzers theses. A read is counted each time someone views a publication summary such as the title, abstract, and list of authors, clicks on a figure, or views or downloads the fulltext. I setting out with definitions, nathanson rejects agentfocused accounts that associate terrorism solely with group violence and rule out the possibility of terrorism. Not surprisingly terrorism has become the top priority of most governments, security agencies, intelligence services and military establishments.
Just war theory sets forth standards, both jus ad bellumrules governing. One of the standard tricks theology teachers used to play in prevatican ii catholic schools was the dilemma of the lesser of two evils. Genuine islam condemns terrorism as clearly as the bishops in ireland. Stephen nathanson takes on these complicated questions, as well as broader just war issues they connect with, in his new fourpart book, terrorism and the ethics of war.
War has been deeply affected in recent years by a variety of social and technological developments in areas such as international terrorism, campaigns of genocide and ethnic. In the war on terror, both sides have taken great pains to justify their actions in moral terms. Just war theory internet encyclopedia of philosophy. Just war, ethics, and terror central intelligence agency. The conference speakers agreed that justifiable war in the old testament required divine sanction. Although it is situated within the category of just war theory, it departs somewhat from most of those in the category, not only in its subject matter but, to a lesser extent, in its focus. Articles just war theory power that saves us both from that moral excess and that political folly. This is the fourth article in a series on the christian just war tradition. A moral argument with historical illustrations is a 1977 book by the philosopher michael walzer. Fsi the europe center just war and the international. In the 1980s, a farleft, femaleled domestic terrorism group. It began in response to an unprovoked attack by those who threaten the security of free societies, it continued with proportionality and discrimination, and it works toward a world of peace and stability, even at the cost.
Bush said on september 20, 2001, whether we bring our. Michael walzer, professor emeritus, school of social science. Jason gatliff argues that some types of terrorism are permissible within a just war framework. S counterterrorism after 911 james kaminski term paper history america publish your bachelors or. The best books on terrorism five books expert recommendations. The justification can be either theoretical or historical. I present in this article is that the tendency to moralize war and terrorism, to stake. The theoretical aspect is concerned with ethically justifying war and the forms that warfare may or may not take. This article on just war and terrorism first appeared in the summer 2016 issue. The burden of american power in a violent world reprint by elshtain, jean isbn. Understanding terrorism and the limits of just war theory. Jan 06, 2020 in the 1980s, a farleft, femaleled domestic terrorism group bombed the u.
The first is whether or not terroristic violence is moral. This classic work examines the issues surrounding military theory, war crimes, and the spoils of war from the athenian attack on melos to the my lai massacre. But an investigation of just war theory and its consistent practice in our socalled war on terrorism demonstrates that it is neither practical nor moral. Jun 26, 2008 michael ignatieffs the lesser evil offers a provocative complement to elshtains primer on the application of just war theory to terrorism. The burden of american power in a violent world jean bethke elshtain on. In the public lecture terrorism and just war, michael walzer, professor emeritus in the school of social science, explores multiple questions. In a just war, a sovereign nation is repelling an unjust aggressor who is inflicting the grave and lasting harm on the nation. The classical just war framework provides the foundation for customary international law as well as the formal laws of armed conflict, in addition to ethical reflection. Just as the destruction of the group cannot be a legitimate purpose of war, observed walzer, so it cannot be a legitimate practice in war. War has been deeply affected in recent years by a variety of social and technological developments in areas such as international terrorism, campaigns of genocide and ethnic cleansing, the global human rights movement, economic globalization, and. In the past, the enemy has always been a hostile country. War has been deeply affected in recent years by a variety of social and technological developments in areas such as international terrorism, campaigns of genocide and ethnic cleansing, the global human rights movement. The purpose of the doctrine is to ensure war is morally justifiable through a series of criteria, all of which must be met for a war to be considered just. She has edited a volume entitled just war theory and authored another book called new wine in old bottles.
Terrorism attacks this notion of innocence and treats civilians as legitimate targets. I examine more closely than i did in my book the implications of. War, terrorism, and the war on terror 5 jeff mcmahan of war are different from those that govern the use of violence in other contexts, that the prohibition of killing the innocent can be overridden in order to destroy a military target as a means of advancing a just cause but not in order to terrorize people as a means of. In 2007 i published a book in which i began to address some of these matters. Feb 01, 2002 this book articulated clearly a lot of what i already felt and feel about the wars in afghanistan, iraq, and elsewhere. Wars are not fought between knights on a jousting field or even two. Oct 22, 2017 the western theory of just war finds genesis in augustines deliberations on christianity and warfare.
Download citation terrorism and just war without abstract find, read and cite. Zinn does an excellent job of articulating the ways in which the media, religion and nationalism were used to whip up support for the war on terror, and in articulating how it was not just the war on iraq that was and is unjust, but the war on afghanistan as well. Ive argued that finlays book is a welcome and very distinctive contribution, focusing on a category revolutionary warfare that is undertheorized. This lecture attempts to answer multiple questions.
The book aroused controversy by the manner in which it drew upon. As force is employed so are sophisticated arguments which directly invoke the just war traditions of. The words rebellion and revolution have gained renewed prominence in the vocabulary of world politics and so has the question of justifiable armed resistance. These rare qualities are once again vividly in force in just war against terrorism. If you want to put it in just war terms, our effectively helping to create the problem, that just reinforces the sense that there is just cause, both a right and a duty to act against isis. So the book looks at how important it is to remember that how you end a war is more momentous than what is happening in the midst of it. Michael walzer and jeff mcmahan have each recently written about the war on isis. Implicit in the theory of just war is a theory of just peace, walzer said.
The book is a kind of intellectual godfather to the research i have tried to do on the endings of terrorist campaigns. She is the author of just war against terror and democracy on trial, among other books. Terrorism and just war americas war on terrorism has once again raised important questions about the proper use of military action. Sep 24, 2019 just as the destruction of the group cannot be a legitimate purpose of war, observed walzer, so it cannot be a legitimate practice in war. Nov 30, 2016 this essay provides a brief overview of the just war tradition and then applies the framework to the problem of contemporary terrorism. The query may seem easy, but it is often answered badly. Everyday low prices and free delivery on eligible orders. The whole entourage came to a halt as soldiers seized the hapless culprit and the tsar descended from his sleigh to check on a bystander wounded by the explosion.
She is a member of the social science research council of the committee on international peace and security. With the new wave of terrorism, many questions have been raised about terrorism as a phenomenon, but also about the possibility of defeating it. Terrorism is a strategy that is chosen from a wide range of possible strategies, according to walzer. Michael walzer on terrorism and just war institute for. A just but not war appr oach to counter terrorism thr oughout history groups and individuals ha ve been willing to act outside the bounds of normative beha viour, but w hat distinguishes the. The 2004 edition adds an epilogue assessing the invasion of iraq and argues that the iraq invasion, like that of. Terrorism and the right to resist by christopher j. Just war theory sets forth standards, both jus ad bellum rules governing if a war may be fought and jus in bello rules governing how a war is fought, standards which must be met if a war is to be considered just. The book will encourage readers to think about biblical wars, though terrorism is too complex for the superficial treatment it received in the book. The difficulty of defining terrorism has led to the cliche that one mans terrorist is another mans freedom fighter, implying that there can be no objective definition of terrorism, no universal standards of conduct in peace. The war on terror, by satisfying the criteria presented, is a just war, if one is of the opinion that any war can be just. Capitol historian william rosenau investigates the may 19th communist organization in a new book about the little.
Thirty years ago, walzer published just and unjust wars, a seminal text on how we think about war and the moral issues surrounding military theory, war crimes. When evaluating any use of force, two questions need to be addressed. Terrorism is the random killing of innocent people, in the hope of creating pervasive fear. Finlay extends just war theory to provide a rigorous and systematic account of the right to resist oppression and of the forms of armed force it can justify. Download it once and read it on your kindle device, pc, phones or tablets. One of the questions that the authors who contribute to this book try to answer is whether just war theory is outdated in this time of terrorism. Unjust wars and, more recently, arguing about war, arguing that because. Just war tradition and the new war on terrorism pew. Published by basic books, it is still in print, now as part of the basic books classics series. A moral argument with historical illustrations basic books classics walzer, michael on. The conference endorsed just war principles and condemned nondefensive attacks. The presupposition of just war thinking is that war can sometimes be an instrument of justice. A second edition was published in 1992, a third edition in 2000, a fourth edition in 2006, and a fifth edition in 2015.
946 295 188 997 505 689 1134 232 1094 1232 941 870 1211 219 294 1058 823 643 1165 1383 318 406 652 19 1463 339 540 1388 256 1297 154 272 961 593 136 626 122 955 1492 1103 1019 767 381 1100 955 337 129 274 79 1407 707